Dan Eernisse Dan Eernisse

We’re in the News Graphic!

Checkout our new write-up in the News Graphic here.

Update: Christina Luick of the News Graphic gave us permission to re-post the original article here. Thanks to Christina and the staff at the News Graphic for taking the time to speak with us and share our story.

Cedar Creek Players becomes a nonprofit

Next performance pending

  • By Christina Luick - News Graphic Staff

  • Sep 1, 2026

CEDARBURG — After a successful inaugural performance, the local theater group Cedar Creek Players is looking to the future of more productions and has become a nonprofit organization.

Cedar Creek Players was introduced in the summer of 2025, and was cofounded by award-winning writer, theater producer, director and filmmaker Graham Killeen. The theater group performed six shows of its first play, Thornton Wilder's "Our Town," last April at the Cedarburg Cultural Center.

Following that, Killeen met Tracy Pelt of Grafton, and the pair discussed whether to move forward with Cedar Creek Players as a for-profit or nonprofit organization.

"In speaking with some of the connections that we've made throughout the community, we just felt like this theater group made sense to be a nonprofit," said Pelt, who is now the board president. She noted that many businesses in the area are very supportive of nonprofits in the community. "We wanted to be an inclusive organization that can do educational opportunities perhaps and also put on shows."

Cedar Creek Players is seeking sponsors and volunteers to help with its next production, which the group hopes to perform next summer. It has not selected its next performance as it is searching for a venue.

Killeen, who now serves as the executive director, compared running a production like planning a wedding.

"On paper, how could a wedding be that complicated and cost that much money? And anybody who's ever planned a wedding knows that it's an extreme amount of money and it's a true amount of time and commitment," he said.

Cedar Creek Players had initially partnered with the Cedarburg Cultural Center with its first performance, but as a nonprofit it is independent from the center.

Cedar Creek Players strives to tell stories that matter to people in Ozaukee County.

"Our goal is trying to tell stories in the community that are relevant to the community ... It's really dealing with the events in life that we all deal with," Killeen said, adding they hope their productions can be conversation starters where people can feel inspired to share their own stories.

"This is such a town that's rich with art and heritage and we feel like this is a community that has a passion for the arts; theater definitely has a home here, and we just feel like we want the community to be a part of it versus a for-profit theater," Pelt said.

Cedar Creek Players also believes that theater is for everyone and it's as important today as ever.

"We really strongly have always believed as a group in lifelong learning, and we feel like theater is as important and relevant to adults as it is for children," Killeen said.

There are four members of the Board of Directors, including Pelt. She grew up doing some theater but now is more of a watcher.

"I'm very passionate about theater," she said.

Pelt serves as vice president on a board for Kids Impact Community. She has also worked with nonprofits in her professional career in operations and marketing.

Pelt said as an organization they are working on introducing it to the community and establishing relationships and partnerships with businesses.

Those interested in sponsoring or volunteering, whether being on stage or behind the scenes, can visit www.cedarcreekplayers.org for more information or email cedarcreekplayers@gmail.com.

"There's just tons of ways to be involved," Pelt said. "And even if you don't know how you want to be involved, we still love to hear from you if you're passionate about theater."

Read More